Merry X-Mas:Cheescake (Masky X Reader X Hoodie)

    "We've got this!" A certain masked proxy said, jumping to his feet barely a second after the announcement. By his side, his fellow proxy in the orange hoodie fidgeted nervously. "Do we have to go first Masky?" Hoodie asked in a hushed voice. Masky nodded his head and walked towards the tree, snatching up a colorful box the size of a large plate. "Come on (Y/n)!" The yellow clad killer said, marching into the kitchen practically dragging Hoodie. 

    Slowly, you rose to your feet, smiling unintentionally at Masky's holiday cheer. He seemed to be the only one enjoying the holiday other than Sally, though you had no idea why. Hoodie was always more reserved about things, but he did seem even quieter than usual about the celebration. 

    "So, you wanna open it?" Masky asked, holding out the box for you to grab. You nodded with a giddy grin, grabbing the box and setting it on the counter to open. You cut the red ribbons holding it closed first, before you ripped the wrapping paper off in one fluid motion. Beneath it all lay a bakery box, one you had seen many times before.

    "You got me a cheesecake. For Christmas?" You asked, not even opening the package. "I knew it was a bad idea Masky..." Hoodie muttered, barely loud enough for you to hear. Suddenly, you burst out laughing, causing the killers to take an uncertain, and even a little scared, step back. "(Y/n)! A-are you alright!?" Masky asked, not taking any chances in moving closer. You nodded your head, violent laughter subsiding bit by bit. "Yes. Yes I am." You said, voice shaking in amusement. "I'm just a little curious as to why you got me a cheesecake." 

    Masky fell silent and folded his arms, clearly not planning on being the one to explain it to you. Hoodie let out a deep sigh before attempting to elaborate Masky's thinking process. "Well... you see, we were kinda hoping... You'd be willing to share it with us." He said, masked face turned towards the floor. You smirked, having assumed as much. Having visited with the killers many times, you began to realize just how in love with cheesecake they were. 

    "Of course I'll share." You said, pulling open the package and searching for a knife. Both proxies immediately perked up and approached the counter next to you. Pulling out three plates, you divided the cake into thirds and placed one slice on each glass platter. "Here we are." You said, placing a fork on each plate from the drawer in front of you. Masky and Hoodie waited for you to take a bite first, hoping to see if you would find the gift acceptable. You snagged one small bite and grinned, the sweet taste of (flavor) cheesecake filling your mouth. "It's delicious!"

    "It is cheesecake after all." Masky said, amusement clearly heard in his tone. The three of you laughed and continued to eat the cheesecake. You kept stealing glances at them both to see if you could catch a glimpse of their faces beneath the mask. Try as you would every time you were around them, you never quite got the chance. You sighed quietly in defeat and stared at your nearly empty plate, about to take another bite when you felt pressure on both of your cheeks. You jumped slightly and looked at their slightly crooked masks. "You guys..." You giggled, hoping your face didn't show the embarrassment you felt. 

"Merry Christmas (Y/n)!"